Skip to content

Big Questions Debate (BQ)

A debate on one question of science, philosophy and religion for the whole year. Five-minute constructives, two question segments and three minutes of prep per side.

NSDADebateFormat checked November 14, 2026

Format at a glance

Who competes
One-on-one or two-on-two
Speaking time
36 minutes of speeches and questions
Prep
3 minutes per side
Topic
One resolution for the whole school year

Big Questions debates a single resolution all school year. The NSDA manual says the topic addresses deeply held beliefs at the meeting point of science, philosophy and religion. The affirmative defends the resolution and the negative defends its opposite, arguing that the resolution is false. Debates may be one-on-one, two-on-two or two-on-one, but entries at the district tournament series and the National Tournament must be individual.

Read the current Big Questions topic: what it asks, what each side can argue, and where to start researching.

Speech order and times

SpeechTimeSpeakerPurpose
Affirmative Constructive5 minAffirmativePresent the case for the resolution.
Negative Constructive5 minNegativePresent the case that the resolution is false.
Question Segment3 minBoth sidesA period of questions between the sides.
Affirmative Rebuttal4 minAffirmativeAnswer the negative case.
Negative Rebuttal4 minNegativeAnswer the affirmative case.
Question Segment3 minBoth sidesA period of questions between the sides.
Affirmative Consolidation3 minAffirmativeNarrow the debate to the main issues.
Negative Consolidation3 minNegativeNarrow the debate to the main issues.
Affirmative Rationale3 minAffirmativeGive the reasons to vote affirmative.
Negative Rationale3 minNegativeGive the reasons to vote negative.

Each side also has 3 minutes of preparation time. In a partnership, teammates must alternate speeches.

Times and speech names are from the NSDA’s manual and event page. The short descriptions are summaries. Compare speech times for every debate event.

Rules to know

From the NSDA’s High School Unified Manual and its page for this event, read on November 14, 2026. Your district or tournament can set details the manual leaves open, so check its invitation too.

  • Stay on the topic

    The manual says arguments must stick to the specific topic, that judges must not evaluate arguments outside it, and that a debater who runs a position not about the topic should lose.

  • The negative has its own burden

    The negative is expected to argue that the resolution is actively false, not only to find gaps in the affirmative case.

  • Judges get a topic primer

    Judges are asked to complete a short training and are given a primer on the topic and format.

Key ideas

  • Consolidation

    The speech that narrows the debate to the few issues that decide it.

  • Rationale

    The last speech, in which each side gives its reasons for the judge’s vote.

  • Question segment

    A three-minute period of questions. There are two in each round.

  • Definitions

    Big Questions resolutions use broad words. The side with the clearer definition usually controls the round.

Common mistakes and how to avoid them

  • Drifting to a different topic

    Tie every argument back to the words of the resolution. Off-topic arguments are not evaluated.

  • A negative case that only attacks

    Build your own reasons the resolution is false before you answer the affirmative.

  • Using jargon from other debate events

    Explain ideas in plain words. Judges may be new to debate.

How to prepare

  • Write a case for each side.
  • Choose two or three clear examples and know them well.
  • Practice explaining a philosophical idea in two sentences.
  • Read the current topic page before you write definitions.

The key ideas, mistakes and preparation steps are Prilo’s advice, not NSDA rules.

Official NSDA sources

Related pages

Prilo is not affiliated with the National Speech & Debate Association. Rules and topics change, so check speechanddebate.org before you compete.

Start practicing for NSDA

Your account opens straight into NSDA practice.