The resolution
Resolved: Technological progress has surpassed humanity’s ability to use it ethically.
Big Questions uses one resolution for the whole 2026-27 school year. The NSDA says members voted July 25 to 31 and the topic was released August 1 at 9:00 a.m. Central.
The NSDA reports that 485 coaches and 1,830 students voted and that this wording received 74% of the coach vote and 57% of the student vote. The other option was “The pursuit of scientific truth is more valuable than the pursuit of philosophical truth.”
Source: the NSDA topics page, read November 14, 2026. If the wording there ever differs from this page, the NSDA’s is right.
What the resolution asks
- The resolution compares two things: how fast technology advances and how well people can use it ethically. It names no single technology.
- The NSDA manual says the Negative in Big Questions defends the opposite of the resolution. Here that means arguing that humanity’s ability to use technology ethically has kept up.
- The manual also says arguments must stay on the topic, and that judges must not vote on arguments outside it.
- “Surpassed” describes the present. A prediction that technology might outrun ethics one day is not enough for the Affirmative, and a hope that ethics will catch up is not enough for the Negative.
Key terms
- Technological progress
- Growth in what tools can do. Decide whether you mean all technology or the most powerful kinds, such as weapons, computing and biotechnology.
- Surpassed
- Gone beyond. The Affirmative must show a gap that exists now, not one that could open later.
- Humanity’s ability
- The capacity of people together, through laws, institutions, norms and personal judgment, and not only what one person can do.
- Use it ethically
- Applying technology in ways that can be morally justified. Each side needs a standard for what counts.
- Governance gap
- The time between a technology becoming available and rules for it being agreed.
What the Affirmative can argue
These are claims and the reasoning behind them, written by Prilo. They are not evidence. Each one needs a source you have read before it goes in a case.
- Technology spreads faster than rules for it can be written.
A new tool can reach much of the world before lawmakers understand it. The Affirmative can argue that when rules always arrive after the harm, ability has fallen behind.
- Some technologies can do damage that cannot be undone.
When one mistake could be permanent, good behavior most of the time is not enough. The Affirmative can argue that holding this power without a reliable way to prevent misuse is the gap the resolution describes.
- Competition rewards using a technology first and asking questions later.
Companies and countries fear falling behind rivals. The Affirmative can argue that even people who want to act ethically are pushed to deploy before they are ready, so the failure is built into the system.
- We keep using technologies after we know the harm.
Knowing that a tool is misused has often not stopped the misuse. The Affirmative can argue this shows a lack of ability, not a lack of information.
What the Negative can argue
- People have built ethical rules for powerful technologies before.
Research ethics codes, safety regulators and international agreements were created in response to new capabilities. In 2021 UNESCO’s 193 member states adopted a recommendation on the ethics of artificial intelligence. The Negative can argue that this is the ability at work.
- Falling short is not the same as lacking the ability.
The resolution is about ability, not about a perfect record. The Negative can argue that misuse shows bad choices by some people, while the tools for ethical use exist and are used every day.
- Technology also expands our ethical reach.
Communication, medicine and information let people notice suffering, organize and prevent harm at a scale that was impossible before. The Negative can argue that progress raises ethical ability along with risk.
- Every generation has feared that its inventions were out of control.
Earlier inventions caused the same worry and societies adjusted. The Negative can argue that the Affirmative has to show why this moment is different, not only that change feels fast.
Start your research here
Primary sources: the documents and organizations the resolution is about. Each link was opened on November 14, 2026. Read them before you read anyone’s summary, including this one.
- NSDA: Topics ↗ · The official wording of every current resolution, the vote totals and the release schedule.
- NSDA: High School Unified Manual ↗ · The Big Questions rules: the burden on each side, the rule that arguments stay on topic, and the speech times.
- UNESCO: Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence ↗ · The global standard on AI ethics adopted by UNESCO’s member states in November 2021.
- OECD: AI Principles ↗ · Principles for trustworthy AI adopted by governments in 2019 and updated in 2024.
- NIST: AI Risk Management Framework ↗ · A voluntary United States framework, released in January 2023, for managing risks from AI.
- World Health Organization: Human genome editing: recommendations (2021) ↗ · A WHO advisory committee’s recommendations for governing a powerful biotechnology.
- United Nations: Universal Declaration of Human Rights ↗ · A shared statement of rights that either side can use as a standard for “ethically.”
The NSDA’s rules require a citation for every piece of evidence read in a round. How to cut evidence cards covers what a citation must include.
Framing and weighing questions
Judges on this topic will have to answer questions like these. Decide your answers before the round.
- What would count as “surpassed”: one technology out of control, or a pattern across many?
- Whose ability is being judged: individuals, governments, or humanity acting together?
- Does one catastrophic risk outweigh a long record of managing ordinary risks?
- If the gap exists but is closing, is the resolution still true?
- Which side’s definition of “ethically” can a judge apply to more than one example?
How to weigh in debate explains the comparisons these questions lead to.
Practice a round on this resolution
A practice prompt written by Prilo. It is not NSDA material. Use it with a partner or your coach and answer out loud. Sparring in Prilo is for Lincoln-Douglas, Public Forum and Policy.
I am Affirmative on the 2026-27 Big Questions topic. My main argument is that technology now spreads around the world faster than laws and norms can respond, so our ability to use it ethically has fallen behind. Give me the arguments a Negative could make that the resolution is false, then questions they could ask me in the question segment.
Then switch sides and do it again. See what Prilo for NSDA does.
Related pages
Prilo is not affiliated with the National Speech & Debate Association. Rules and topics change, so check speechanddebate.org before you compete.