Skip to content

Public Forum topic, November/December 2026: European NATO members and the nuclear ban treaty

Resolved: European members of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization should ratify the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons.

NSDACurrent topicWording checked November 14, 2026

The resolution

Resolved: European members of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization should ratify the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons.

This is the NSDA Public Forum topic for November and December 2026. The NSDA announces the January 2027 topic on December 1, 2026 at 9:00 a.m. Central.

The NSDA reports that 629 coaches and 3,281 students voted and that this wording received 57% of the coach vote and 44% of the student vote. The other wording on the ballot was “The Republic of Korea should pursue an independent nuclear deterrent.”

Source: the NSDA topics page, read November 14, 2026. If the wording there ever differs from this page, the NSDA’s is right.

What the resolution asks

  • The actor is the European members of NATO. NATO lists 32 member countries. Two of them, the United States and Canada, are in North America, so the resolution is about the other 30. Türkiye sits mostly in Asia, so be ready to say whether your definition of “European” includes it.
  • The action is ratifying the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW). In the United Nations treaty glossary, ratification is the act by which a state agrees to be bound by a treaty. Signing a treaty does not bind a state by itself.
  • The United Nations Office for Disarmament Affairs says the treaty bans developing, testing, producing, acquiring, possessing, stockpiling, using or threatening to use nuclear weapons. It also bans deploying nuclear weapons on a member’s territory and helping any state do what the treaty prohibits.
  • On November 14, 2026 the United Nations Treaty Collection listed 96 signatories and 75 parties to the treaty. No NATO member was on either list, so the resolution asks for a change from what every one of these countries does now.
  • “Should” asks whether ratifying would be better than not ratifying. Neither team has to prove what governments will actually do.

Key terms

Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW)
A United Nations treaty adopted on July 7, 2017 that entered into force on January 22, 2021. Debaters also call it the ban treaty.
Ratify
To formally agree to be bound by a treaty. A country that ratifies the TPNW takes on every prohibition in it.
Nuclear deterrence
Preventing an attack by keeping the ability to answer it with nuclear weapons. NATO says the purpose of its nuclear capability is to preserve peace, prevent coercion and deter aggression.
Nuclear sharing
NATO’s name for the arrangements in which some Allies provide aircraft that can carry nuclear weapons in a conflict. NATO describes these on its nuclear deterrence page.
Nuclear weapon states in NATO
NATO names three: France, the United Kingdom and the United States. Two of them are European, and the treaty’s ban on possessing nuclear weapons would apply to them.
Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT)
The 1968 treaty, in force since 1970, meant to stop the spread of nuclear weapons and further the goal of nuclear disarmament. NATO says all of its members are parties.

What the Pro can argue

These are claims and the reasoning behind them, written by Prilo. They are not evidence. Each one needs a source you have read before it goes in a case.

  • Ratifying would take nuclear weapons off European soil and out of European war plans.

    The treaty bans hosting nuclear weapons and helping others use them. Pro can argue that a country that no longer hosts or plans for these weapons is less likely to be struck first in a crisis and less exposed to an accident.

  • The humanitarian cost of any nuclear use is too high for these weapons to stay in a defense policy.

    A nuclear detonation cannot be limited to soldiers. Pro can argue that a policy which depends on threatening civilians is one democracies should give up, and that ratifying is how a state gives it up in law.

  • European ratification would strengthen the global rule against nuclear weapons.

    Treaties gain force as more states join. Pro can argue that wealthy, allied democracies joining would put more pressure on nuclear-armed states than the current members can, and would back up the disarmament goal the NPT already sets.

  • Security in Europe does not have to rest on nuclear weapons.

    Pro can argue that NATO’s conventional forces and the alliance’s mutual-defense promise would remain after ratification, so the choice is not between nuclear weapons and no defense at all.

Hear the other side’s answers firstGive the debate coach one of these contentions and get the rebuttals an opponent could run.
Start practicing

What the Con can argue

  • Ratifying would break NATO’s nuclear deterrent.

    NATO states that it will remain a nuclear alliance for as long as nuclear weapons exist. The treaty bans hosting nuclear weapons and assisting with them, so a member that ratified could not take part in nuclear sharing. Con can argue this weakens the protection every member relies on.

  • The ban would bind only one side.

    Nuclear-armed states outside NATO are not parties to the treaty. In its December 2020 statement the North Atlantic Council argued that a world where NATO gives up nuclear weapons while its challengers keep theirs is not safer. Con can extend that reasoning to a Europe that ratifies alone.

  • The treaty competes with the system that already limits nuclear weapons.

    The same North Atlantic Council statement says the treaty is at odds with existing non-proliferation and disarmament agreements. Con can argue that effort is better spent on the NPT, which the nuclear-armed NATO members have joined.

  • Ratification would split the alliance.

    France and the United Kingdom would have to give up their arsenals, and members that host weapons would have to send them back. Con can argue that the dispute over who ratifies and when would damage trust inside NATO even before any weapon moved.

Start your research here

Primary sources: the documents and organizations the resolution is about. Each link was opened on November 14, 2026. Read them before you read anyone’s summary, including this one.

The NSDA’s rules require a citation for every piece of evidence read in a round. How to cut evidence cards covers what a citation must include.

Framing and weighing questions

Judges on this topic will have to answer questions like these. Decide your answers before the round.

  • Both sides claim to lower the risk of nuclear war. Which team explains more clearly how its world makes a launch less likely?
  • Does the resolution mean all European members ratify together, or each one deciding alone? The Con’s alliance arguments change depending on the answer.
  • How should a judge compare a harm that is unlikely but enormous with one that is likely but smaller?
  • Over what time should the round be judged: the first years after ratification, or the decades after?
  • Whose security counts: the countries that ratify, their allies, or everyone?

How to weigh in debate explains the comparisons these questions lead to.

Practice a round on this resolution

A practice prompt written by Prilo. It is not NSDA material. Use it with a partner, or paste it into the debate coach in Prilo and answer what comes back out loud.

I am Pro on the November/December 2026 Public Forum topic. My contention is that ratifying the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons would end nuclear sharing in Europe and make a nuclear strike on those countries less likely. Give me the rebuttals a Con team could run, then crossfire questions aimed at each link in my argument.

Then switch sides and do it again. See what Prilo for NSDA does.

Related pages

Prilo is not affiliated with the National Speech & Debate Association. Rules and topics change, so check speechanddebate.org before you compete.

Start practicing for NSDA

Your account opens straight into NSDA practice.