What weighing is
At the end of most rounds each side is still winning at least one argument. The judge has to choose between them. If neither debater explains how, the judge chooses alone, by a standard you did not get to argue for. Weighing is you making that comparison first.
These are debate conventions, not NSDA rules. The NSDA’s manual sets speech times and evidence rules and leaves how to compare arguments to debaters and judges.
Six ways to weigh
- Magnitude
How bad or how good is the result? Use it when your impact is more severe than theirs for each person it touches.
- Scope
How many people does it reach? Use it when your impact is wider, even if theirs is deeper.
- Probability
How likely is it to happen? Use it when your argument has fewer steps that could fail than theirs.
- Timeframe
How soon does it happen, and how long does it last? Use it when your impact arrives first or theirs is far off and uncertain.
- Reversibility
Can the harm be undone? Use it when your side avoids a permanent loss and theirs risks one that could later be repaired.
- Prerequisite
Does one impact have to be solved before the other can be? Use it when their benefit depends on something only your side protects.
A worked example
The November/December 2026 Public Forum topic asks whether European NATO members should ratify the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons. Suppose the Pro is winning that hosting nuclear weapons makes a country a target, and the Con is winning that removing them weakens deterrence. Here is how each side could weigh. The lines are reasoning written for this page, not evidence.
| Mechanism | What the Pro could say | What the Con could say |
|---|---|---|
| Magnitude | A nuclear strike on a country that hosts weapons would be catastrophic for that country. | A war that deterrence failed to prevent could involve the whole alliance. |
| Probability | Our harm needs only one accident or one miscalculation while the weapons stay. | Their harm has not happened in the decades these weapons have been in Europe. Ours follows directly from removing the deterrent. |
| Timeframe | The risk from hosting exists every day until ratification. | The security gap opens the day the weapons leave. Any benefit from a stronger norm is years away. |
| Reversibility | A nuclear detonation cannot be undone. A weaker deterrent can be rebuilt. | Trust inside an alliance, once broken, is slow to rebuild. |
Both sides have something on every line, which is normal. The round goes to the team that says which line matters most and why. A Pro might argue that reversibility comes first because a mistake with nuclear weapons allows no second try. A Con might argue that probability comes first because a harm that has not occurred in decades should not outweigh one that follows directly from the resolution.
How to say it in a speech
- Name the two impacts being compared
“Their best argument is X. Ours is Y.” If you cannot name theirs fairly, the judge will not trust your comparison.
- Pick one or two mechanisms
Choose the comparisons you actually win. Listing all six sounds like a checklist.
- Give the reason
“We win on probability” is a label. “Their argument needs three things to go wrong and ours needs one” is weighing.
- Answer their weighing
If they say magnitude and you say probability, tell the judge which matters more here and why.
- Say it as an “even if”
“Even if you believe their contention, you still vote for us, because…” This is the sentence a judge writes down.
Weighing in Lincoln-Douglas
Lincoln-Douglas rounds are judged through a value and a criterion, so weigh in two layers. First, say whose criterion the judge should use and why. Second, show that you win under it. If you can, show that you also win under your opponent’s criterion. On “De-extinction is unethical,” an affirmative using a criterion of protecting those who cannot consent would weigh harm to the animals first, and would argue that benefits to human knowledge do not count under that test.
Common mistakes
- Weighing only in the last speech
Start in the Public Forum summary, the Lincoln-Douglas rebuttals or the Policy rebuttals, so the other side’s failure to answer it counts.
- Weighing an argument you are losing
Weighing compares impacts. It does not rescue an argument whose warrant was answered. Win the argument first.
- Using the words without the comparison
Saying “we outweigh on scope” with no reason gives the judge nothing.
- Ignoring the judge’s standard
In Lincoln-Douglas, weigh under the criterion. An impact that does not connect to the value in the round does not count for much, however large it is.
Related pages
Prilo is not affiliated with the National Speech & Debate Association. Rules and topics change, so check speechanddebate.org before you compete.