The resolution
Resolved: De-extinction is unethical.
This is the NSDA Lincoln-Douglas topic for November and December 2026. The NSDA announces the January/February 2027 topic on December 1, 2026 at 9:00 a.m. Central.
The NSDA reports that 636 coaches and 3,167 students voted and that this wording received 54% of the coach vote and 57% of the student vote. The other wording on the ballot was “The United States ought to vest ecosystems with legal rights.”
Source: the NSDA topics page, read November 14, 2026. If the wording there ever differs from this page, the NSDA’s is right.
What the resolution asks
- The Affirmative defends the sentence as written: de-extinction is unethical. The Negative argues that it is not.
- There is no actor and no policy. Nobody is asked to ban or fund anything. The NSDA manual says a Lincoln-Douglas resolution calls for a value judgment.
- The NSDA topics page does not define “de-extinction.” Whether it covers cloning, gene editing of a living relative, selective breeding, or all three is something you argue.
- The claim is general. The Affirmative has to explain why the practice is unethical as a whole, and the Negative can test that with a case where it seems acceptable.
Key terms
- De-extinction
- Producing living animals or plants that resemble a species that has died out. The company Colossal lists the woolly mammoth, the thylacine, the dodo, the dire wolf, the moa and the bluebuck as its species.
- Proxy
- The word the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s Species Survival Commission uses in its 2016 guiding principles: a stand-in for an extinct species, not the species itself.
- Unethical
- Wrong by some moral standard. The round usually turns on which standard: outcomes, duties, or what the act says about our character.
- Value and criterion
- The value is the goal your case upholds, such as justice. The criterion is the test for whether that goal is met.
- Opportunity cost
- What is given up when money, time or attention goes to one project and not another.
- Moral hazard
- Taking more risk because you believe a loss can be undone.
What the Affirmative can argue
These are claims and the reasoning behind them, written by Prilo. They are not evidence. Each one needs a source you have read before it goes in a case.
- De-extinction makes animals suffer for a human project.
Creating a proxy means experiments on living animals, surrogate mothers of another species, and offspring born with no parents or herd of their own kind. The Affirmative can argue that causing this harm for curiosity or publicity is wrong whatever the result.
- It takes resources away from species that are still alive.
Conservation money and attention are limited. The Affirmative can argue that spending them on a species already lost, while living species decline, is the wrong moral priority.
- It weakens the reason to prevent extinction.
If people believe extinction can be reversed, protecting habitat feels less urgent. The Affirmative can argue that a practice which invites that carelessness is unethical even when its supporters mean well.
- Releasing a proxy gambles with living ecosystems.
The places these species lived have changed since they disappeared. The Affirmative can argue that introducing an engineered animal puts existing species and people at a risk they did not agree to and that cannot be taken back.
- It promises a restoration it cannot deliver.
A proxy is a new organism that resembles the old one. The Affirmative can argue that calling this a return of the lost species is a kind of deception and treats animals as products.
What the Negative can argue
- Repairing a harm we caused is not unethical.
Many extinctions were caused by people. The Negative can argue that trying to restore what was destroyed is an act of responsibility, and that an attempt at repair cannot fairly be called a wrong.
- The same science helps living species.
The Species Survival Commission’s guiding principles treat proxies as a possible conservation tool for restoring biodiversity and making ecosystems more resilient. The Negative can argue that a practice with that purpose is not unethical in itself.
- “Unethical” is too broad a verdict.
Risks to animals and ecosystems can be regulated, reduced or avoided in particular projects. The Negative can argue that a practice which can be done responsibly is not unethical as a whole, which is what the resolution claims.
- “Unnatural” does not mean “wrong.”
Much of medicine and farming changes nature. The Negative can argue that the Affirmative needs a reason beyond discomfort, and that the knowledge gained has value of its own.
Start your research here
Primary sources: the documents and organizations the resolution is about. Each link was opened on November 14, 2026. Read them before you read anyone’s summary, including this one.
- IUCN Species Survival Commission: Guiding principles on creating proxies of extinct species for conservation benefit (2016) ↗ · The conservation body’s own principles for when creating a proxy could help, with the full document to download.
- U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service: Endangered Species Act ↗ · How United States law lists, protects and recovers living threatened species, with a link to the statute.
- Convention on Biological Diversity: text of the Convention ↗ · The treaty that sets international goals for conserving biodiversity.
- Colossal Biosciences ↗ · A company attempting de-extinction describes its own projects. Read it as the advocate’s account, not as neutral evidence.
- NSDA: Topics ↗ · The official wording of every current resolution, the vote totals and the release schedule.
The NSDA’s rules require a citation for every piece of evidence read in a round. How to cut evidence cards covers what a citation must include.
Framing and weighing questions
Judges on this topic will have to answer questions like these. Decide your answers before the round.
- What makes an act unethical in this round: its results, a duty it breaks, or what it shows about us?
- Is the resolution about de-extinction in principle, or as it is practiced today?
- Who counts in the weighing: individual animals, whole species, ecosystems, or future people?
- If the benefits and the harms are both uncertain, which side should have to prove more?
- Does a proxy count as de-extinction? Your answer decides which examples belong in the round.
How to weigh in debate explains the comparisons these questions lead to.
Practice a round on this resolution
A practice prompt written by Prilo. It is not NSDA material. Use it with a partner, or paste it into the debate coach in Prilo and answer what comes back out loud.
I am Affirmative on the November/December 2026 Lincoln-Douglas topic. My value is justice and my criterion is protecting those who cannot consent. My contention is that de-extinction is unethical because it pulls money and attention away from saving living species. Give me the rebuttals a Negative could run, then cross-examination questions aimed at each link.
Then switch sides and do it again. See what Prilo for NSDA does.
Related pages
Prilo is not affiliated with the National Speech & Debate Association. Rules and topics change, so check speechanddebate.org before you compete.